I didn’t write yesterday because we had a general election in Aotearoa, and our rules are that you can’t do anything that might be perceived as encouraging someone to vote until the polls close, and I wanted to see how the results unfolded. Unlike the blue wave in the US, we had a very strange and muddled outcome, and the result won’t be clear for some time, but in the wake of the absolute shellacking the right took in the US I’ve been thinking about what it means for our lives online.
I gave up on old twitter a long time ago. I don’t think you should hang out places where the owner’s chatbot produces csam, and nazis are welcome, even if the jokes are good. But I really noticed lately how many people, particularly journalists and pundits, are still hanging out over there because they have audiences and think it matters. And then last month, it suddenly became fashionable to say that x the everything app was “back”. John Gruber, the apple blogger (is that even a thing any more? no) announced his return, saying:
You may not like it that X has re-found its footing under Elon Musk’s ownership, but it has... There are hundreds of interesting people and accounts I follow that post on X very regularly and do not post anywhere else at all.
Also, he described the culture on x as “friendly and inclusive”, something only a white man could write. The same week the Center for Studies of Organized Hate released its report on dehumanisation and threats of violence against Muslims. The study found that almost two-thirds of reported posts that threatened violence against Muslims or dehumanised them were still up after being reported. The study also found that posts from paid subscribers were removed at lower rates than posts from ordinary users. Anti-South Asian hate speech on that platform has surged by 240%. But whatever, the memes, I guess.